Pina Colada Pie – my first post!

After some deliberation I’ve decided to start a baking blog.  As luck would have it, this very week that I set out to start it we are in the midst of a major heatwave.  It’s day 4.  102 degrees today. So, I decided to outsmart the heat and make an icebox pie.  I found a delicious sounding recipe for a pina colada pie that suited me and I bought all of the necessary ingredients.

 Lesson 1: read the directions very, very thoroughly prior to setting your mind to a baking project.  The crust baking was unfortunate but tolerable because it was 6 minutes and I just escaped into my singular air conditioned room (the bedroom).  What I wasn’t prepared for until, oh, reading step 2, was the fact that I’d be standing over a double boiler.  In my 97 degree kitchen.  (Not exaggerating.)  But, I set out to do this and I’m doing it!  It took longer than expected, as the gelatin was supposed to set in 10 minutes.  Guess that’s a bit longer when it’s 97 degrees in your kitchen.  Even in my fridge it took close to an hour.  Use your judgement and monitor the filling for consistency and thickening.

Crust baked.  Pie filling poured.  Pie setting in fridge overnight.  Bzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzap.  Electricity is out.  Great.  Now my starting-to-set-pie is in a fridge that will not be cold for very long.  Seriously folks, just don’t bake in a heatwave.  The forces of nature and technology are ALL against you.

It’s now 11pm, I’m in my pajamas, teeth brushed, bedtime prayers said and I’m filling a cooler with my goods to take the contents of my fridge and freezer, including the cursed Pina Colada Pie, to my office kitchen.

First thing this morning, I was able to snap some requisite pictures of the pie for the blog.  I encourage you all to try this yummy treat, but just don’t do it during a heatwave.

Cursed Pina Colada Pie 

adapted from Icebox Pies by Lauren Chattman

Vanilla Wafer Crust 

50 Vanilla wafer cookies
5 T unsalted butter, melted and slightly cooled
1/8 t salt
1 t vanilla extract

  • Preheat over to 350
  • In food processor, chop cookies until finely ground.  Combine crumbs, butter, salt, and vanilla in bowl, stir until moistened
  • Press mixture evenly across bottom and up sides of 9-inch pie pan, packing tightly
  • Bake until golden, 6-8 minutes.  Cool completely before filling

Pina Colada Pie Filling

2 T cold water
2 t unflavored gelatin
2/3 c sugar
3 large eggs
6 oz pineapple juice (canned)
½ c unsweetened coconut milk
¾ c heavy cream 

  • Place cold water in bowl, sprinkle with gelatin.  Let gelatin stand to dissolve
  • On a double boiler, whisk together sugar, eggs, pineapple juice, and coconut milk, making sure metal bowl does not touch bottom of saucepan.  Heat, whisking constantly, until 160 degrees on thermometer.
  • Remove bowl from double boiler and whisk in gelatin.  Let stand on ice or in fridge until it begins to thicken, whisking occasionally.
  • Whip heavy cream to soft peaks and fold into pineapple mixture.
  • Fill pie shell.  Cover with plastic and refrigerate until completely set, at least 6 hours and up to 1 day. 
This entry was posted in Baking Jumbles and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Pina Colada Pie – my first post!

  1. Lisa says:

    Ha ha! I’m laughing in my head for a couple of reasons. First, same thing happened to me making dinner tonight with the power going out. And I thought, “Really, how much heat can one stove burner generate?’ And now I’m dripping with sweat. Second, I’m laughing because this sounds like such a typical Kristin-esque adventure that would have occurred once upon a time in college! I like your blog idea…will you be updating your posts through facebook, too?

  2. Oh so I’m not the only one? 🙂 I don’t think my blog will be connected to my facebook posts (at least not for now) – I don’t want to innundate people too much. But you’ve given me something to think aboutk, maybe I’ll reconsider that since I only expect to post about 1x/week…..

  3. Brenda says:

    Funny you started this blog. I just saw Julie & Julia this week.
    Work is gonna love to reap the benefits of your hard work!!
    Did you haul your booty to the office at 11:00 in your “jammies”?
    How was the pie? Did you decorate it w/ umbrellas? Is there any left or did they snarf it up at work?

    • yes, I hauled my sleepy self to work in my jammies (granted i sleep in a tank top and shorts). Work almost always reaps the benefits of my baking, and they scarf it down pretty fast. Pie was good, refreshing in the summer heat. I enjoyed that movie, Julie & Julia. That, howver, would be quite an undertaking!

  4. Monica H says:

    Congrats on your new blog. Pina Colada Pie! It sounds delicious and I’m glad it turned out despite your troubles in the kitchen.

    I wish I could see a larger close of that pie slice. mmm!

  5. oneordinaryday says:

    Oh no! I’ve had more kitchen experiences like this than I care to remember. Even last week, while my son was trying to make the three musketeers bars, we kept losing electricity because of the heat and rolling blackouts. We stuck it out and I bet your co-workers are glad you did too. The pie sounds perfect for a hot summer day.

    Congrats on starting your blog. I hope you have fun with it!


  6. Pingback: Challah with Raisins (corrected) | Sweet Jumbles

Leave a Reply to Monica H Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s